上海交通大学：《供应链管理 Supply Chain Management》课程教学资料_Case Studies_Evaluation Criteria_Barilla SPA

Case:Barilla SPA Score Question weight(equally weighted) specifications case ①Question1 5 ● Give more or have a deep insight than expected AQ1 1,2,3,4,5 )reasonable explanations 4 ● Give the normal solutions with appropriate explanations AQl(four of 1,2,3,4,5)+some reasonable explanations 3 Give most of the solutions AQ1 (three of 1,2,3,4,5) 2 o Just give some of the solutions AQ1(two of1,2,3,4,5) 1 Have mentioned but haven't really solve the problems AOl (less than two of 1.2.3.4) ②Question2 ● really grasp the nature of the problems with in-depth AQ2(1,2,3,4*)+careful analysis analysis 4 ● give the main points of the problems AQ2(1,2,3)+reasonable analysis 3 just give some of the main points two of the AQ2(1.2.3)+analysis 2 ● too simple or rough in the answer despite giving some two of the AQ2(1,2,3)but without of the points analysis 1 ● haven't really grasp the points Less than two of the AQ2(1,2.3) ③question3 5 ● really grasp the nature of the problems with in-depth AQ3(two of 1(1,2,3,4*)+two of analysis than expected the 2(5,6,7)+2*)or other creative solutions+detailed analysis ● give the main points of the problems AQ3(two of 1(1,2,3,4*)+two of the 2(5,6,7))+some analysis 3 ● just give some of the main points AQ3(three of1(1,2,3,4*,5,6,7) 2 ● too simple or rough in the answer despite giving some AQ3(two of1(1,2,3,4*,5,6,7) of the points 1 ● haven't really grasp the points Less than one Of AQ31,2,3,4*,5,6,7) ④question4 5 ● propose more solutions creatively and effectively than Five or more of AQ4(1 to 11)or expected other creative solutions 4 ● propose normal solutions and they can really solve these Four ofAO4(1 to 11) problems 3 ● the solutions are not complete or some of them can't Three of AQ4(1 to 11) help in solving these problems 2 ● the proposed solutions works to some extent but can not Two of AQ4(1 to 11) solve these problems essentially ● the proposed solutions can't help in solving these Less than one of AQ4(1 to 11) problems or the solutions are too limited total Above the overall 4 questions score (①+②+⑥+④)/4

Case: Barilla SPA Score case Question & weight(equally weighted) specifications ○1 Question 1 5  Give more or have a deep insight than expected AQ1 （ 1,2,3,4,5 ） + reasonable explanations 4  Give the normal solutions with appropriate explanations AQ1(four of 1,2,3,4,5)+some reasonable explanations 3  Give most of the solutions AQ1（three of 1,2,3,4,5） 2  Just give some of the solutions AQ1（two of 1,2,3,4,5 ） 1  Have mentioned but haven’t really solve the problems AQ1（less than two of 1,2,3,4） ○2 Question 2 5  really grasp the nature of the problems with in-depth analysis AQ2（1,2,3,4*）+careful analysis 4  give the main points of the problems AQ2(1,2,3) + reasonable analysis 3  just give some of the main points two of the AQ2(1,2,3)+ analysis 2  too simple or rough in the answer despite giving some of the points two of the AQ2(1,2,3) but without analysis 1  haven’t really grasp the points Less than two of the AQ2(1,2,3) ○3 question3 5  really grasp the nature of the problems with in-depth analysis than expected AQ3(two of 1(1,2,3,4*)+two of the 2(5,6,7)+2*) or other creative solutions+ detailed analysis 4  give the main points of the problems AQ3(two of 1(1,2,3,4*)+two of the 2(5,6,7))+ some analysis 3  just give some of the main points AQ3(three of 1(1,2,3,4*,5,6,7)) 2  too simple or rough in the answer despite giving some of the points AQ3(two of 1(1,2,3,4*,5,6,7)) 1  haven’t really grasp the points Less than one of AQ3(1,2,3,4*,5,6,7) ○4 question4 5  propose more solutions creatively and effectively than expected Five or more of AQ4(1 to 11) or other creative solutions 4  propose normal solutions and they can really solve these problems Four of AQ4(1 to 11) 3  the solutions are not complete or some of them can’t help in solving these problems Three of AQ4(1 to 11) 2  the proposed solutions works to some extent but can not solve these problems essentially Two of AQ4(1 to 11) 1  the proposed solutions can’t help in solving these problems or the solutions are too limited Less than one of AQ4(1 to 11) total score Above the overall 4 questions (○1 +○2 +○3 +○4 )/4