上海交通大学：《供应链管理 Supply Chain Management》课程教学资料_Case Studies_Evaluation Criteria_Meditech Surgical

Case:Meditech Surgical Table 1 Score Score items weight specifications case Accuracy in finding the problems(question1)& Questionl need to be answered 0.3 in two aspects ● Find more or have a deep insight than expected AQ1 (1,2,3,5)+two of the AQl (4*,6*,7*)+ reasonable explanations ●Find the normal problems(1,2)with appropriate AQ1(1,2,3,5+ reasonable explanations explanations 3 ● find most of the problems AQ1 (three of 1,2,3,5) 2 ● just find some of the problems AQ1 (two of 1,2,3,5 1 ● Have mentioned but haven't really grasp the problems AQ1 (less than two of 1,2,3,5) or too simple in the analysis of the problems Comprehensiveness and intrinsic quality in the Question2 and question 3 analysis of the causes of the problems(question2,3)&0.4 5 Give the causes of the problems than expected with AQ2(1,2,3,4,7)+two of AQ2 in-depth analysis or really grasp the nature of the (5*,6*，8*)+AQ3(1,2) problems +careful analysis 4 give main causes of the problems but analyze AQ2(1,2,3,4,7) +AQ31,2H incompletely in question 2,the point of forecast and reasonable analysis demand is important (1,2,3,6,7); 3 ● just give some of the causes and superficial analysis Three of the AQ2(1,2,3,4,7)+AQ3(1,2)+ analysis 2 ● haven't grasp the main causes,or haven't give Two of the AQ2(1,2,3,4,7)+one complete analysis ofAQ3(1,2) 1 ● haven't really grasp the causes of the problems Less than two of AO2(1.2.3.4.7)+less than one of AQ3(1,2) ③ Effectiveness in the proposed Question 4 solutions(question4)&0.3 5 ● propose more solutions creatively and effectively than AQ41,2,3,4十AQ4(5*,6*) or expected other creative solutions 4 propose normal solutions and they can really solve these AQ41,2,3,4) problems ● the solutions are not complete or some of them can't Three of AQ4(1,2,3,4) help in solving these problems

Case:Meditech Surgical Table 1 Score case Score items & weight specifications ○1 Accuracy in finding the problems( question1) & 0.3 Question1 need to be answered in two aspects 5  Find more or have a deep insight than expected AQ1（1,2,3,5）+two of the AQ1 （ 4*,6*,7* ） + reasonable explanations 4  Find the normal problems(1,2) with appropriate explanations AQ1(1,2,3,5)+ reasonable explanations 3  find most of the problems AQ1（three of 1,2,3,5） 2  just find some of the problems AQ1（two of 1,2,3,5 ） 1  Have mentioned but haven’t really grasp the problems or too simple in the analysis of the problems AQ1（less than two of 1,2,3,5） ○2 Comprehensiveness and intrinsic quality in the analysis of the causes of the problems( question2,3) & 0.4 Question2 and question 3 5  Give the causes of the problems than expected with in-depth analysis or really grasp the nature of the problems AQ2（1,2,3,4,7）+two of AQ2 （ 5* ， 6* ， 8* ） +AQ3(1,2) +careful analysis 4  give main causes of the problems but analyze incompletely : in question 2 , the point of forecast and demand is important (1,2,3,6,7) ; AQ2(1,2,3,4,7) +AQ3(1,2)+ reasonable analysis 3  just give some of the causes and superficial analysis Three of the AQ2(1,2,3,4,7)+AQ3(1,2)+ analysis 2  haven’t grasp the main causes ,or haven’t give complete analysis Two of the AQ2(1,2,3,4,7)+one of AQ3(1,2) 1  haven’t really grasp the causes of the problems Less than two of AQ2(1,2,3,4,7)+less than one of AQ3(1,2) ○3 Effectiveness in the proposed solutions( question4) & 0.3 Question 4 5  propose more solutions creatively and effectively than expected AQ4(1,2,3,4)+AQ4(5*,6*) or other creative solutions 4  propose normal solutions and they can really solve these problems AQ4(1,2,3,4) 3  the solutions are not complete or some of them can’t help in solving these problems Three of AQ4(1,2,3,4)

2 the proposed solutions works to some extent but can not Two of AQ4(1,2,3,4) solve these problems essentially 1 the proposed solutions can't help in solving these Less than one of AQ4(1,2,3,4) problems or the solutions are too limited total Above the overall 3 points score (0.3*①+0.4*②+0.3*③) Table 2 for students Name Item Score items weight Your comments number scor e ① Accuracy in finding the problems(question1) 0.3 回 Comprehensiveness and intrinsic quality in the 0.4 analysis of the causes of the problems question2,3) ③ Effectiveness in the proposed solutions 0.3 question4) Your (0.3*①+0.4*回+0.3*国) total score

Table 2 for students Name Item number Score items weight Your scor e comments ○1 Accuracy in finding the problems( question1) 0.3 ○2 Comprehensiveness and intrinsic quality in the analysis of the causes of the problems ( question2,3) 0.4 ○3 Effectiveness in the proposed solutions ( question4) 0.3 Your total score (0.3*○1 +0.4*○2 +0.3*○3 ) 2  the proposed solutions works to some extent but can not solve these problems essentially Two of AQ4(1,2,3,4) 1  the proposed solutions can’t help in solving these problems or the solutions are too limited Less than one of AQ4(1,2,3,4) total score Above the overall 3 points (0.3*○1 +0.4*○2 +0.3*○3 )